Home Home Home
Home
Translation Jobs
Sembunyikan Panel
Members Log On

Nama pengguna

Kata sandi
Click to get help
Pilih Bahasa Situs
IDBahasa Indonesia
ENEnglish
Forum
Saat ini Anda meramban sebagai tamu. Harap masuk untuk mengakses fitur lebih banyak.
Moderator
Jacek K., Nanna Mercer
Format pesan
Informasi utas
Kegiatan Terakhir November 22, 2009 12:20 PM

37 balasan
2653 tampilan

Pencarian dalam Situs
Pemberitahuan

Tuas pemberitahuan email

XML RSS Feed
Rekomendasikan Kami
stumbleupon|digg|del.icio.us|reddit|facebook
Legenda
Pesan yang Dikirim:
5000 5000
2000 2000
1000 1000
500 500
100 100
25 25
Pengodean Warna:
  • Administrator
  • Moderator Forum
  • Pengguna Terdaftar
The aim of every artist is to arrest motion, which is life, by artificial means and hold it fixed so that a hundred years later, when a stranger looks at it, it moves again since it is lifeWilliam Faulkner
Halaman: 1 2 3 4
Kembali Balas
Are languages dying?

Have you noticed any symptoms that may suggest that languages are dying, or your particular language is? Have you noticed that more and more words form another language are taking your language over; that some of the words do not even have grammatical forms that fit your language structure, or any language, in fact, you would like to discuss. Have you noticed that people have no interest, especially young people, in their native language? Have you noticed that people do not even want to learn certain languages? What is the future of languages? Do they need CPR? Or an inpatient intensive treatment to get back on their feet? Does it matter?  

Opsi Suara
16 votes - [64%]
.  
1 vote - [4%]
.  
4 votes - [16%]
.  
0 votes - [0%]
.  
3 votes - [12%]
.  
1 vote - [4%]
.  

Dikirim:
September 27, 2009 12:03 PM
Entri #185588- membalas #185586
Jacek K.
TC Master
Bahasa ibu: Polish
Bergabung: February 18, 2003
Lokasi: Poland
 
RE: Are languages dying?

Originally written by Derek Thornton on September 27, 2009 5:51 PM

L'oro del Reno sounds like some cheap wristwatch bought in Nevada.

How does Złoto Renu sound to you? You can almost feel interferences from złoty, the lawful currency of the Republic of Poland...

Speaking of Wagner, I was actually thinking of going back to http://www.osterfestspiele-salzburg.at/en/programm/2010/ where Sir Simon Rattle and the Berlin Philharmonic will complete the realisation of Richard Wagner’s Ring des Nibelungen in 2010. I don't think I will ever make it to Bayreuth... 



[Diedit oleh Jacek K. pada September 27, 2009 12:09 PM]

Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 27, 2009 1:25 PM
Entri #185593- membalas #185571
Janus Jacquet
Extreme Veteran
100100100252525
Bahasa ibu: Danish
Jumlah entri: 389
Bergabung: May 7, 2004
Lokasi: Denmark
 
RE: Are languages dying?
Originally written by Derek Thornton on September 27, 2009 3:49 PM

The same applies by extension to languages, They are the raw material for texts, nothing more. Again, what the writer makes with them can be beautiful or ugly. Apart from certain nuances, all languages are utilities - they have a usefulness which will vary according to the circumstances in which they are used.

I see languages as coding systems, lifeless and faceless and I can see no way that a coding system can have "beauty". Some have turned out to be very useful, like the Morse code, French, and COBOL and some have faded away leaving no trace, like the semaphore, Greenlandic Norse and ADA..

I see no reason why any of this should be mutually exclusive. The fact that languages are raw material or utilities doesn’t prevent them from having differing aesthetic value.

Similarly, I would most certainly consider programming languages like COBOL and Ada (side note: ADA = Apple Design Awards; the language is called Ada and its name is not an acronym but named after a person called Ada) the same way, as having aesthetic values as well as being merely tools. Ada, for example, is a language I would consider extremely ugly, COBOL is sort of neutral aesthetic-wise, and a language like PHP is very beautiful in my eyes.

I would carry this on to any other utility or utensil: I like my kitchen knives to be sharp and cut well, but I’d also like for them to have a beautiful, sleek design. Apart from purely utilitarian and practical reasons, there are several and important aesthetic reasons that I prefer to work on a Mac, in OS X, to working in Windows or Linux on a PC. Similarly, while any language will, generally speaking, enable the speaker to get the message through more or less equally well, there’s a reason I prefer to use Icelandic or Irish Gaelic to using Arabic or Greenlandic: the latter have significantly lower aesthetic value to my ears than the former.


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 28, 2009 1:55 AM
Entri #185613- membalas #185593
Jacek K.
TC Master
Bahasa ibu: Polish
Bergabung: February 18, 2003
Lokasi: Poland
 
RE: Are languages dying?

Overheard this morning a rant on the radio about the omnipresence in Polish of the word "project" adopted from English. Just as is the case with "looking to" in English which gradually eliminates other verbs (Post #185551), "project" is now used for just about any initiative which formerly would be called exhibition, show, performance, screening, publication of a volume of poems. In this particular broadcast, they were happy to announce a series of conversations with authors rather than a new "project."


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 28, 2009 6:18 AM
Entri #185621- membalas #185613
Liliana Boladz-Nekipelov
Expert
2000500100100100100
Bahasa ibu: Polish, English
Jumlah entri: 2907
Bergabung: September 13, 2008
Lokasi: United States
 
RE: Are languages dying?

It is a beauty compared to meila i skena.  


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 28, 2009 8:21 AM
Entri #185631- membalas #185613
Dodo Kaipdodo
TC Master
Expert
100050025
Bahasa ibu: Lithuanian
Jumlah entri: 1544
Bergabung: August 8, 2007
Lokasi: Lithuania
 
RE: Are languages dying?

Originally written by Jacek K. on September 28, 2009 1:55 AM

Overheard this morning a rant on the radio about the omnipresence in Polish of the word "project" adopted from English. ... "project" is now used for just about any initiative which formerly would be called exhibition, show, performance, screening, publication of a volume of poems.

Curious... or perhaps not... but this precisely is what`s happening in Lithuania, too.


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 28, 2009 8:22 AM
Entri #185632- membalas #185593
Derek Thornton
TC Master
Bahasa ibu: English
Bergabung: April 30, 2007
Lokasi: Germany
 
RE: Are languages dying?

Originally written by Janus Jacquet on September 27, 2009 6:25 PM
I see no reason why any of this should be mutually exclusive. The fact that languages are raw material or utilities doesn’t prevent them from having differing aesthetic value.

You are right, it doesn't prevent them from having differing aesthetic values. It is just that in my opinion their aesthetic value is totally irrelevant to their raison d'être.

Originally written by Janus Jacquet on September 27, 2009 6:25 PM
ADA = Apple Design Awards; the language is called Ada and its name is not an acronym but named after a person called Ada. 

Thank you. I hadn't forgotten that. It was just that, judging by past record, I feared that nobody here would be old enough to remember the Lady Ada Lovelace, whose pretty picture appeared all over the green box in which the compiler was delivered so I decided to sacrifice accuracy for recognizability and typed it as ADA which, to my mind, stood a chance of being seen as a programming language.

I once worked with a programmer who looked like her. The whole get-up was notably unsuited to crawling about behind the patch panel to see what had broken off this time but I must say that she smelt very nice.

I could have written PASCAL instead and I would still not have made it into Pascal after old Blaise, mainly because his image is far less attractive. Maybe I should have written COBOL as Cobol after Dr. Grace Cobol of Remington-Rand, the inventor, who was also something of a good-looker. 

Originally written by Janus Jacquet on September 27, 2009 6:25 PM
Ada, for example, is a language I would consider extremely ugly, 

Well, there you see the problem - the language might be ugly but the shrink-wrapped box was not. What was a poor red-blooded man to do? Sacrifice aesthetic value for carnal lust?

Originally written by Janus Jacquet on September 27, 2009 6:25 PM 
I like my kitchen knives to be sharp and cut well, but I’d also like for them to have a beautiful, sleek design.
 

I tend to run for cover when women and sharp kitchen knives enter the conversation. It is a primitive reaction, I know, but then I have had my unfortunate experiences ...

Derek


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 28, 2009 8:57 AM
Entri #185634- membalas #185631
Jacek K.
TC Master
Bahasa ibu: Polish
Bergabung: February 18, 2003
Lokasi: Poland
 
RE: Are languages dying?

Originally written by Dodo Kaipdodo on September 28, 2009 2:21 PM

Originally written by Jacek K. on September 28, 2009 1:55 AM

Overheard this morning a rant on the radio about the omnipresence in Polish of the word "project" adopted from English. ... "project" is now used for just about any initiative which formerly would be called exhibition, show, performance, screening, publication of a volume of poems.

this precisely is what`s happening in Lithuania, too.

This is evidence, though, that our languages are very much alive and adapting... See Post #185567...


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Dikirim:
September 29, 2009 3:15 AM
Entri #185683- membalas #185632
Shiong-Fong Lew
Bahasa ibu: English
Bergabung: March 28, 2004
Lokasi: Malaysia
 
RE: RIP

Originally written by Derek Thornton on September 28, 2009 9:22 PM

I could have written PASCAL instead and I would still not have made it into Pascal after old Blaise, mainly because his image is far less attractive. Maybe I should have written COBOL as Cobol after Dr. Grace Cobol of Remington-Rand, the inventor, who was also something of a good-looker. 

Originally written by Janus Jacquet on September 27, 2009 6:25 PM
Ada, for example, is a language I would consider extremely ugly, 

Well, there you see the problem - the language might be ugly but the shrink-wrapped box was not. What was a poor red-blooded man to do? Sacrifice aesthetic value for carnal lust?

[

 

Rather than beauty, it seems to be dictated by the master of the universe in the form of fast-changing industrial needs, unless of course you have the luxury of buying art pieces for arts sake. Even Microsoft seems to say monthly updates are the norm, and to hell with perfection..

I was taught FORTRAN in university and did projects using Z80 assembly language and Pascal, but right out of university, it was C language and Intel assembly language.

 


Balas|Buat Penawaran|Edit|Hapus
Halaman: 1 2 3 4
Kembali Balas
Home | Forum | Album Foto | Pencarian
Utas terbaru | Hari Ini | Minggu Ini | 25 Teratas
Statistik Forum | Yang Online | Kutipan Acak
New TC Seluler | Setelan Forum | Masuk
TranslatorsCafé.com

Pilih Bahasa Situs English | Español | Bahasa lainnya...

Hak cipta © ANVICA Software Development 2002—2009. Semua hak dilindungi.
Kebijakan Privasi. Syarat dan Ketentuan Penggunaan. Penggunaan situs ini diartikan sebagai persetujuan.
Kirim surat komentar dan saran ke webmaster TranslatorsCafe.com
Direktori penerjemah, juru bahasa, dan agen penerjemahan.

Sanggahan Forum: Pendapat yang dinyatakan di dalam forum adalah pendapat penulisnya dan bukan berarti pandangan dari pemilik situs dan/atau moderator. Jika pembaca menganggap sebuah entri dianggap mengganggu, ajukan keluhan ke moderator forum yang terkait. Keluhan akan ditanggapi dalam waktu 24 jam, namun ketahui bahwa moderator mungkin tinggal di tempat dengan zona waktu berbeda. Penggunaan forum merupakan bentuk persetujuan Anda dengan Aturan Pengiriman Entri Forum.